Industry guru Dave Taylor offers free tech support on a wide variety of technical and business topics, including HTML, Apple iPhone, online advertising, Cascading Style Sheets, Web design, management, Unix, Linux, search engine optimization, online dating, Mac OS X, shell script programming and Microsoft Windows.

Calling All Cellphone Carriers: America Needs Innovation

The Japanese and American cell phone markets are opposite like lamb and tuna fish. That was one of the first things that I noticed when I spent a few weeks there two summers ago. I've always had a less than optimal view of our cell phone market's infrastructure where the best network gets the ugliest phones and the worse network gets all of the good looking phones but without the reception. That's why when I went to Japan and saw that multiple companies had summer cell phone lines coming out like seasonal clothing lines, I was taken aback.

I was used to a network here where my phone's novelty wears off within the hour that I get it, and then I'm trapped in a contract for far too long with expensive escape fees. In Japan though, I could customize my plan (daytime only service or TV reception for example) with a good looking phone and solid service even underground in subway stations, according to Japanese cell phone customers.

If the cell phone world is so perfect in Japan, why is it so fundamentally flawed here in the States? Why is it so rigid, straight forward and uncompromising? Why as consumers haven't we demanded the flexibility that the Japanese cell phone industry exudes?


Dave's Answer:

First and foremost it’s the fault of the service providers.

Why the rigidity? Why the inability to work with creative and innovative companies to push the progress of what a phone can do? Instead of making phones smaller and shinier, why not try to incorporate things into phones that we as consumers don’t even know we need yet?

When the iPhone was brought to Verizon, they sent Apple away, dismissing Steve Jobs and company’s requests for freedom within their network as crazy talk. AT&T, maybe sensing what was to come (or what should come), took the dive and allowed Apple to run more freely than anyone ever has when working with cell phone providers, allowing revenue sharing, Visual Voicemail, a full iTunes store a cell phone and then the App Store. But when the iPhone captured the hearts of gadget-lovers in America, Japan sat unscathed, texting away on phones that were years ahead of phones on the American market.

japanese cellphone vending machine.jpg
Japanese Cellphone Vending Machine
Image used under Creative Commons license, original from d0ug&r0byn @ Flickr

The iPhone’s success here, or rather its lack of success in Japan has to do with one major factor: the home computer, a piece of technology that the iPhone relies heavily on for music dumping and software updates, a piece of technology that is not as widely embraced in Japan as it is in the States.

There they use their cell phones for everything from making phone calls to recording videos, playing music and paying for drinks at vending machines so why don’t we? After the carrier’s inflexibility, it’s only fair to blame the other side of the coin, the companies that make and provide the phones that we use.

Japan’s seasonal lines are scrapped across the Pacific for phones that are churned out by the week with poor interfaces and cheap touch screens. Samsung’s latest venture is a group of phones that set out to either rip off the iPhone or capture people too stubborn to switch off of Verizon, I’m not entirely sure yet. It’s too bad that Samsung doesn’t have half of the engineering prowess that Apple does and subsequently turns out phones that Verizon won’t recommend to you in their stores for the simple fact that they don’t want to deal with you in a few weeks when it breaks.

I’m tired of the choice between the expensive smart phone or the cheap, breakable piece of plastic. I’m tired of going back to the store two months after I buy a phone to get a new one because the old one stopped working.

It’s time that American cell phone companies embrace what technology can do in terms of innovating the cell phone market. Why not do things the way that the Japanese do, incorporating e-wallets into phones with RFID chips and cameras that aren’t 1.5 megapixel pieces of junk? We as customers need to demand from providers freedom in our contracts, the ability to customize our plans to fit exactly what we do with our phones. Everyone is different, shouldn’t our cell phone plans reflect our needs? Moreover, our phones should reflect our personalities instead of the drones in I,Robot.

I want freedom and I want it now! I just don’t want to move to Japan.

Zack Shapiro is a staff writer for the CU Independent and an active blogger. You can find him on his website ShutUpInternet.com and on Twitter as @zackshapiro


Help others find this article at Del.icio.us, Digg, Netscape, Reddit, and Stumble Upon    

Ringaza Free Bonus Ringtones and Wallpapers!


Subscribe!

Never miss another useful Q&A article again! Subscribe to AskDaveTaylor with Google Reader.

Comments

Great question and interesting answer, but I think Dave is too reserved. The main problem is the myopic management of the US carriers. For example, when they started out they billed for 'getting on the network' which made sense. You use the network, you get billed. Once they started to make money, they never change.

The carriers are too small minded to see that they could be making a lot more money with a different setup. For example, in almost every other country, carriers only bill the outgoing usage. If Dave calls me, Dave pays and I don't. Same with texting/SMSs. This opens up some many possibilities. First off, you get a lot more customers. You can prepay, use very little, and people can contact you as need. Secondly, you can open your network to advertisers (shudder). I know it sounds bad (and it is), but because US carriers charge you to RECEIVE a SMS they are missing out on a lot of money they could make from SMS marketing. But those idiot CEOs just can't see past the next quarter.

Rant over.

Posted by: Dempsey at April 25, 2009 12:02 AM

Dempsey,

Thank you for your comment. Your second paragraph really makes a great point and I wish I had included that in my answer!

The carriers are definitely too small-minded. The prospect of a network having its users being able to jump phones or jump companies freely and easily scares hell out of them, Why let their users be happy with customizable plans or the ability to easily switch phones without a new contract when they can just price gouge everything.

In the next five years I hope we see more innovation in the cell phone market by companies who want to push the status quo. Android is a good start, as is the iPhone, but it's going to take an altered business model, I think, to really start the innovation.

-Zack

Posted by: Zack Shapiro at May 16, 2009 10:39 AM

I have something to say, now that you mention it, but ...
Starbucks coffee cup I do have a lot to say, and questions of my own for that matter, but first I'd like to say thank you for all your efforts on this Web site by buying you a cup of coffee!

I do have a comment, now that you mention it!











Remember personal info?


Please note that I will never send you any unsolicited commercial email. Ever.

While I'm at it, please note that by submitting a question or comment you're agreeing to my terms of service, which are: you relinquish any subsequent rights of ownership to your material by submitting it on this site.








Ask Dave Taylor: The iPhone App: Advertisement


Uniblue: Free Virus Scan

Follow me on Twitter @DaveTaylor

Search
Find just the answers you seek from among our 2300+ free tech support articles by using our Lijit search engine.


Help!





Subscribe to
Ask Dave Taylor!

Add to Google Reader
Add to My Yahoo!
Subscribe in NewsGator Online

RDF   XML

Free Updates!
Sign up and get free weekly updates and special offers on books, seminars, workshops and more.


Recent Entries
Book Links
© 2002 - 2009 by Dave Taylor. All Rights Reserved.

Note: This web site is for the purpose of disseminating information for educational purposes, free of charge, for the benefit of all visitors. We take great care to provide quality information. However, we do not guarantee, and accept no legal liability whatsoever arising from or connected to, the accuracy, reliability, currency or completeness of any material contained on this web site or on any linked site.

[whiteboard marker tray]
"Ask Dave Taylor®" is a registered trademark of Intuitive Systems, LLC.